If you have been charged with second-degree murder, you need to understand more than the name of the offense. Is the prosecution alleging an intentional killing, participation in a felony or fatal reckless conduct showing depraved indifference? Those are different cases to defend. At Vasiliou Law, we identify the precise allegation and build the defense around the evidence needed to prove or challenge it.
Our Astoria office represents clients facing serious criminal charges in Queens. Call (347) 967-6141 for a free initial consultation about an investigation, arrest or existing murder prosecution.

Our team includes Anastasios Sarikas, a former Bronx prosecutor admitted in New York in 1984, and Kaliopi Vasiliou, admitted in 2013. Both completed National Criminal Defense College training.
In a murder prosecution, that criminal law background is relevant to practical work: understanding how the prosecution presents an inference of intent, preparing witnesses and cross-examination, challenging evidence where appropriate and advising on the risks of trial or a proposed resolution. Our role is to defend you and give you a clear assessment, including where the evidence presents difficult issues.
We do not treat a second-degree charge as a lesser concern because it is not first-degree murder. It carries potential life imprisonment. The preparation should reflect both that consequence and the specific facts alleged against you.
Penal Law Section 125.25 contains several forms of second-degree murder. The subdivision cited in the charging document matters because the requirements are not the same.
Under the ordinary intentional murder provision, the prosecution must prove that the accused caused a person’s death with the intent to cause a death. The New York courts’ model instruction describes intent in terms of a person’s objective or purpose. The prosecution must establish the elements beyond a reasonable doubt. It is not enough simply to establish that a death followed an encounter.
Section 125.25 also covers depraved indifference murder and felony murder. Those allegations do not depend on proving the same intent to kill. Further provisions address particular circumstances involving children and specified sexual offenses. An explanation of one subdivision should not be applied automatically to another.
This page focuses on defending an alleged intentional killing. If the indictment contains alternative murder counts, we explain the requirements of each and how the prosecution’s theories differ.
There may be no direct statement of intent. Prosecutors may instead ask a jury to infer it from actions, words, the nature of the injury or the circumstances surrounding the incident. A defense must address those inferences with a careful account of what the evidence actually shows.
For example, a recording may begin after the confrontation started. A witness may describe movements without being able to hear what was said. A medical finding may help explain an injury without conclusively establishing a person’s objective. We compare those sources rather than allowing an incomplete account to stand as the whole incident.
Identity and intent are separate questions. Even strong evidence that someone was present does not automatically prove they committed the fatal act or intended a death. Conversely, disputing intent does not resolve a reliable identification. We identify which parts of the prosecution’s account can realistically be challenged and what evidence is needed for each challenge.
Causation also requires attention. The prosecution must connect the accused’s conduct to the death under the applicable legal standard. The medical chronology, competing explanations and expert findings may be important. We assess whether the scientific or medical conclusions support the proposition for which they are being offered.
The appropriate defense may involve mistaken identity, a failure to prove intent or causation, justification, or another issue supported by the facts. These positions have different legal consequences. We explain whether a proposed argument challenges guilt altogether, challenges the degree of homicide or concerns whether particular evidence can be used.
Penal Law Section 35.15 governs force used in defense of a person. Deadly force has specific requirements. Reasonable belief, the alleged threat, who initiated the encounter and whether retreat was required can all matter. The statute contains exceptions, so the analysis must fit the situation.
Evidence from before the fatal act can be critical. We examine recordings, injuries, witness accounts and communications for the context of the alleged threat. A claim of fear cannot simply be accepted or rejected without examining the circumstances against the legal requirements.
Extreme emotional disturbance is an affirmative defense in an appropriate intentional murder case. If established, it reduces the offense to first-degree manslaughter rather than excusing the homicide completely. It requires an extreme emotional disturbance with a reasonable explanation or excuse, considered under the applicable statutory test. Ordinary anger or distress does not automatically establish it.
This defense involves a different burden from a challenge to an element of murder. Under Section 25.00, the defendant must establish an affirmative defense by a preponderance of the evidence. A statutory defense other than an affirmative defense, once raised at trial, must be disproved by the prosecution beyond a reasonable doubt. We explain what that means for the particular defense and the evidence available.
A confession or identification can appear decisive while still requiring close scrutiny. We examine how questioning occurred, whether the recording is complete, how identification procedures were conducted and whether searches complied with the law. Depending on the facts, motions and hearings may determine whether evidence can be used at trial.
A suppression issue is not a promise that charges will be dismissed. The question is both whether a legal basis exists to exclude evidence and how that ruling would affect the prosecution’s remaining proof.
Second-degree murder is a class A-I felony. An ordinary indeterminate sentence under Penal Law Section 70.00 has a maximum of life imprisonment and a minimum generally fixed between 15 and 25 years. Particular statutory convictions can require life without parole. Age and other applicable rules must also be considered.
The minimum period is not a release date. Eligibility to seek parole does not mean parole will be granted. If the indictment includes other charges, the possible sentences and how they relate to one another need separate advice. We discuss the actual exposure so that decisions about a plea offer or trial are made with an understanding of the consequences.
We review the charging documents and the prosecution’s disclosed material, identify further records or witnesses that may matter and assess appropriate motions. Where physical or medical evidence raises a specialist issue, we consider the need for an independent expert. Preparation must address both the legal requirements and how the evidence will be presented and challenged in court.
Your decisions also matter. Whether to testify, consider a plea offer or proceed to trial should be discussed with counsel in light of the evidence and available options. We explain the reasoning behind the advice and the uncertainties that remain. A difficult prosecution still requires a defense based on your individual circumstances.
If a relative has been arrested, give us their full name, custody location, court documents and upcoming dates if known. Do not wait to seek help because some details are missing. Preserve relevant records without editing them, and avoid discussing the facts on social media or in conversations that may be recorded.
Call Vasiliou Law at (347) 967-6141 or contact our Astoria office for a free initial consultation. Explain whether police are investigating, an arrest has just occurred or an indictment is already pending.
For the wider section, visit our murder defense overview. Our first-degree murder page explains the additional statutory circumstances involved in that charge.
Learn more about our attorneys and read client reviews of Vasiliou Law.
References include Penal Law Section 125.25, Section 70.00, Section 35.15, Section 25.00, Criminal Procedure Law Section 710.20 and the courts’ extreme emotional disturbance instruction. Sources checked October 17, 2026. General New York legal information is not advice for an individual case. Contacting the firm does not itself establish an attorney-client relationship.
© 2026 Vasiliou Law. All rights reserved.